Proxy Figures and the Pause in Brian Blanchfield’s Queer Narratives

November 17, 2026

Back in 2018, a new friend handed me Brian Blanchfield’s Proxies with a knowing smile and the assurance that I would fall for it. I have to admit that this friend and I were just beginning a mutual crush, a fact that colors the gesture in a familiar way within queer circles. The gift language of good lesbian friendship often goes like this: share a book whose narrator spirals between seeking knowledge and courting failure; offer words about the intimate textures of sex, even a hint at defining the act itself, and include a line that declares, “We had sex, some of us, felt the act itself, and drew arousal from it.”

I approached Proxies with no checkpoint of expectation, and, as it happened, the effect did not require a gatekeeping moment. Later that winter, my new friend and I would steal a kiss in a snow-slick cab ride home, after lingering over glasses of orange wine at Molasses Books. Yet more than the queerness that threads through Proxies, what seized me was Blanchfield’s talent for slipping between forms with almost no concern for the boundaries a reader might assume. Was he able to traverse genres because he keeps those boundaries porous, or is the permeability itself what makes the work possible? Either way, the book read as a confident contradiction to itself—Blanchfield’s prose seems to exist for its own sake, even as it quietly pioneers a fresh approach to how a memoir might behave.

Structured as 24 brief essays, Proxies fuses autobiography with topics that appear nearly arbitrary. First published in January 2016, each essay pushes the limits of writing the self. Blanchfield begins with intent, yet the starting point almost inevitably escapes him, whether by topic or by form. Across pieces about talking owls, housesitting, and frottage (that ongoing challenge of pinning down gay sex), the collection of “essays near knowing” slides between the lush, floral cadence of a seasoned poet and the plainspoken frankness of a memoirist; it sits at the crossroads of scholarly references and vivid cultural memory. While the prose can feel like an unregulated stream of consciousness, Blanchfield’s preface frames the project as “a concession to imprecision, a failure,” yet each essay remains tightly structured: a topic is announced, followed by a subheading that always reads “Permitting shame, Error and Guilt, Myself the Single Source.” Then the narrative unfolds.

Proxies arrived in the national discourse at the outset of Donald Trump’s first term. A decade later, as we contend with a second administration, the targeting of queer rights continues at a breakneck pace, and the work stands as a crucial reminder for queer archives.

In her 2017 review of Proxies, Claire Lowdon notes that this repetition “on the page becomes mantra, then superstition, then OCD-style neurosis.” She observes that Blanchfield is “forcibly staking out territory for himself and declaring it a safe space. It doesn’t work like that. You have to earn it.”

This cadence of subject introduction, subheading, and exploratory body is essential to the book’s authority. But Blanchfield isn’t trying to persuade anyone that his story is true or factually precise. Instead, Proxies and every frame within it bend the usual contracts of memoir.

Indeed, Blanchfield is a solitary authority here, but he is a flawed one; he foregrounds this fact. With error on his side, his narrative is not a record of truth but a memory best recalled. Unlike conventional memoir, which aims to recount what happened, Blanchfield privileges witness over testimony. He becomes a witness to remembering his past and invites the reader to accompany him in the act of discovery as it happens. He even reserves the right to check facts and memory in a chapter that sits apart from the other essays, aptly titled Corrections, placed at the back of the book after he has laid bare his topics in full. The divide between his telling and the factual apparatus makes facts almost inconsequential; he has built a form of truth through process. A genre that does not contain him makes his authority all the more compelling.

Proxies does not claim to be a memoir. It chooses a language for itself that refuses to be conventional.

In On Reset, Blanchfield invokes Gertrude Stein’s idea that “repetition is never exact repetition, because the human registering it is different the second time.” If you take the time to return to each title, subtitle, and frame within Proxies, every revisit to a seemingly ordinary topic sparks a charged attention to the possibility of error; the pressure to be “accurate” becomes both maddening and casual, nearly dissolving into itself.

Proxies arrived at the outset of the first Trump era. A decade later, in the era of a second administration, queer rights continue to erode rapidly, and the work remains a pivotal beacon for queer archives. Yet beyond its themes, Proxies also marks an early example of how writing that foregrounds error can function as a defiant mode of resistance and as a move toward a more authentic version of memoir.

Today’s publishing market appears to be watching its own collapse, a reality especially evident for memoirs. Memoirs and nonfiction more broadly are not performing well financially. While the decline is tied to a shifting publishing ecosystem—media outlets folding, houses shrinking, readers leaning toward bite-size content, authors going unpaid, and a chorus of crisis rhetoric—the drift may partly be explained by a reluctance to loosen the marketing tactics that once buoyed memoirs into the spotlight.

Proxies does not claim to be a memoir. It forges its own idiom. Yet returning to the text in an era when believability is under daily challenge, the book offers me reassurance as I launch my own genre-blurring debut. It reminds me that queer narratives have always offered a reprieve from formulaic failure and it gives me faith that queer writers will continue to treat Proxies as both a cherished gift and a kind of secret handshake—an invitation to imagine what reading looks like when we understand ourselves, as individuals and within the broader community, to be worth pursuing even when quieter, subtler stories refuse to chase mass popularity the way flashier memoirs often do.

And as Blanchfield closes his improvised autobiography with a gentle line, “Our first date was on Election Day, 2010. …we kissed in the beams, which made the little globes on the ghostery bush galactic. We mark our anniversary from there, and we tell everyone every year we re-elect each other. Campaign comes from the Latin campus. Open country. And country from contra. All the area out in front of you, facing you. No term limits. The queer heart.”

__________________________________

Nanny Nanny

Nanny Nanny by K Chiucarello is available from Ecco.

Isabela Reyes

Isabela Reyes

I write about books as quiet places where memory, imagination, and culture meet. At PLAI, I explore literature through reviews, author stories, reading reflections, and the small details that make a story stay with us long after the final page.