AITA for Approaching an Author Who’s Out for Lunch?

November 19, 2026

Hey there, howdy!

Welcome back to the merrily inebriated advice column that loves a good pint as much as a good plot twist. Yes, it’s time for another sparkling edition of Am I the Literary Asshole, a corner where big personalities come to both propel and stir the pot. I’m the host behind this page, and today we’ll get right down to business. We’ve gathered a cache of intriguing dilemmas, so we’ll jump in with some flair and ceremony.

Let’s pour a batch of frosty martinis and sip while we examine our first question, shall we?

1) Is it in poor taste to approach writers during their off hours? For instance, when they’re out to lunch or dinner, away from the clamor of a festival or a reading? Appreciate your time!

We’ve likely touched on a version of this before, but revisiting it for readers new to the column feels right. After a weekend spent at the Texas Book Festival, I’m particularly primed to discuss.

What happens here should unfold much as it would in any ordinary social setting. Before you approach the writer in question, you should first read the room.

Is the person with kids? Are they on a call? Do they have a lot of bags or a big suitcase, or are they in the middle of paying a bill or chatting with a server? Are they grabbing a coffee? Are they typing furiously on a laptop or speaking in hushed tones to someone? Are they sharing a kiss or holding hands at a quiet dinner for two? Are they in a public restroom? If any of these clues apply, I’d suggest waiting. Hold back. Pause.

But if the writer is simply out and about and seems open to a moment of interaction—perhaps enjoying a quick drink at the bar or browsing at a neighborhood indie shop—then I say go for it! Some authors are naturally more introverted (not everyone is as exuberant as I am), but a courteous, light introduction followed by a brief exit is the key to success here.

Being recognized by someone who genuinely admires your work is a lovely feeling. In general, I’d advocate letting yourself enjoy a friendly word when the moment presents itself.

I hope that helps!

A martini is a marvelous thing, and so are you! Now, let’s move on to the second question:

2) There’s a woman at my workplace who reads during her break. She favors the same kinds of books I love—cozy fantasy—and I’d like to strike up a chat. I’m worried this might come off as inappropriate. I don’t want her to think I’m flirting.

Why would chatting about what someone is reading strike you as romantic? Asking about a book should be a perfectly neutral topic in a professional setting.

Think of it this way: you already know this person; you both work at the same company. It isn’t a random encounter with a stranger.

Of course, in a casual, everyday scenario, such a line could be interpreted as flirtatious and less neutral. For example, if you walked up to a stranger at a bar and asked about their book, that could come across as a come-on (even if that isn’t your intention) because 1) they’re a stranger and 2) bars are common places for introductions. But with a coworker, it should feel reasonable to ask about a book during a break, especially if you share an author you both enjoy.

They might respond with interest or not; it’s their break, after all. They may prefer to sit quietly and read. But you’ll never know unless you try. And to me, this seems like a nice chance to make a new friend. I’d say go for it.

Here’s hoping you discover a new reading buddy during break time! Get out there and start a conversation.

So far, so good! I’ll pour us one more martini apiece as we tackle the final question of the day:

3) I’m stuck in a reading rut. For the last year I’ve been fixated on a narrow genre, a pattern that follows a familiar formula and predictable endings. I should branch into more “literary” works, but each time I try one I draw a blank. Is it bad to stick to one type of book?

I don’t see a problem with enjoying something that brings you happiness. Perhaps you’re in a phase where your mind can only handle these predictable tales. The world is chaotic and full of upheaval; having something safe—even if it means knowing how it ends—can feel comforting. It’s the same impulse that makes people rewatch the same television shows repeatedly.

That said, it’s okay to wonder whether you should broaden your reading horizons, and it seems you’ve already started to explore a bit!

Continue devouring the material you currently enjoy. If reading starts feeling like a chore, it can resemble an unpaid job, so look for ways to keep the experience enjoyable. As long as you gain something meaningful from it, that’s what truly matters.

Before we wrap today, I wanted to share an email from the organizers behind the Silent Book Club (in response to my previous column about a club charging extravagant membership fees). I’ll pass along their message, regardless of whether the particular club is trademarked—the information is useful either way:

Hi there! I’m Guinevere, the cofounder and CEO of Silent Book Club. I came across your Lit Hub article about someone asking for $100 per month for a Silent Book Club meetup, and I was appalled. Silent Book Club does not permit local organizers to profit from events—it violates the terms of our organizer agreement that grants volunteers a non-exclusive license to use our trademark.

For more than a decade, we’ve built a values-driven community that welcomes all readers. We host meetups in public spaces to support local businesses, we do not partner with Amazon/Audible, and a portion of our annual profits is donated to literary nonprofits. We recently finished a Banned Books campaign that raised funds for the American Library Association.

If it’s true that there is a Silent Book Club organizer charging $100 per month without our knowledge, that person is violating our terms and we must revoke their license.

And there you have it! If you happen to be the anonymous person who submitted the last question and have any follow-up details about this situation, please feel free to reach out to Guinevere directly.

Join me next time when I answer more of your anonymous inquiries (please send them here) and hopefully I’ll get to share another round of martinis with you. So glad we’re friends!

Cordially,

With warm regards,

__________________________

Worried you’re the literary asshole? Send Kristen an email at AskKristen@lithub.com, or submit anonymously here.

Isabela Reyes

Isabela Reyes

I write about books as quiet places where memory, imagination, and culture meet. At PLAI, I explore literature through reviews, author stories, reading reflections, and the small details that make a story stay with us long after the final page.