The Blank Page Demystified: A Guide to Starting Fresh

November 20, 2026

The twelve shooters have been picked, the rifles are primed for loading, and as dawn breaks and the trench is prepared, my moment to occur will arrive.

Or perhaps, not to occur at all.

My brothers, all eleven of them, must scorn me, must deem me fragile. And yet, among this swaggering lot, only I hold indispensability. We may resemble one another, twelve figures standing in a gleaming, black metallic row, outwardly identical, but inwardly, where it truly counts, I am distinct, chosen for a higher mission.

Mock me as you will. Without me, their bullets would be aimless, plagued by guilt for what looms just ahead. It is my existence, and mine alone—and solitary, so solitary—that lifts them from that fog of remorse.

When I was born—in a metaphorical sense—taken from the polished steel cohort I had belonged to, the Captain pressed into me the heavy load of duties and traits. Yes, literally pressed, at the moment of my making, pressed, inserted, a powderless core into the heart of my housing, making me incapable of causing harm henceforth. All the while praising me as he worked, this dashing officer naming me his little blank, his favorite cartridge: You are unlike the others, though you may share the same exterior in brand, build, heft, and sleek design. That’s the point, that no one can tell from the surface that you are uniquely distinct—relish the honor of your concealed, fusillade function, my dear little sweetheart, the battle-tested Captain urged softly, smiling as he spoke, not for you to be discharged and propelled, not for you to feel the air rupture as you advance with cold efficiency, not for you to savor the moment of impact, the flesh bursting, the eye socket pierced, the heart ripped apart, the taste of blood, the last cry, ah, you will not spend the rest of eternity recalling that nightmare of the last cry.

Sound and flash, yes, those you will enjoy, the Captain promised even as he was stripping me of powder, draining me of explosive filings, sound and flash and a reddish glow are essential so none of the soldiers who obey the order to fire can discern to whom you were assigned, whether the bullet that ends the prisoner’s life is theirs or a dud, your performance of a grand spectacle will be so flawless, your mimicry of a genuine projectile and its recoil so convincing, your constricted muzzle so seemingly primed and smoking, that each of those twelve human warriors will believe he was the one to whom your safe, dull shell happened to be allotted, and thus spared the heavy burden of having taken a life, and the life of someone who was once and remains their friend, each of them capable of sleeping a bit better tonight pretending the live round was not his, just as each of them prays—still, as the rifles are handed out and they align in line—that their weapon has chosen innocence rather than ammunition.

Only you know which among them is the fortunate, inert candidate, the Captain continues as he adds the final touches to his task, only you will stay hidden inside the barrel, observing your eleven brothers marching toward the bound deserter I’ve tied to the tree beyond the field, you will remain here within the rifle, the Captain vows, bidding farewell to the real bullets as they whiz forward to take their toll on the man who used to be their comrade, who shared rations with them, who traded tall tales of nights of fevered intercourse in a brothel, I was once like them, you will have the privilege, my Captain insists, giving me one last pat, almost a caress, as he seals me away from any tampering, the privilege, he repeats, of easing the guilt of the executioners, only you alone know for sure which among them bears no fault, only you know that when the trigger of the rifle is pulled, no slug will be sent, no momentum will gather, no delivery will occur, oh you are a marvel, my little pretend cartridge, my favorite.

With this final hymn of praise, he is finished and, satisfied that I will not fail, he departs to attend to his other duties.

I should remain calm.

And yet, now that he leaves me to my own devices, now that my own thoughts begin to crowd out his pep talk, now that he is no longer there to console me for any sense of manly fulfillment or release, now that his words fade, certain doubts creep into my marrow, threading through my shaft, awakening a question I cannot dismiss: Am I truly innocent, as the Captain has insisted far too often? Perhaps he has hammered on this point precisely because he judges me, in the end, guiltier than my brutal kin. After all, it is only my limited presence beside these eleven properly functioning cartridges that makes the act of surpassing air and flesh and space possible, the lungs shredded, the body of the frightened deserter—whose only fault was fear and a wish to return to his mother or his lover or his kin or his village—what if it is my presence, my reduction of their responsibility, that prevents the unit from rising up, from shaking their heads and saying no, we will not be part of this atrocity, firing toward the heavens and sky, racing toward the freed companion, untying him, and vanishing with him into the luminous black night, what if I am the obstacle keeping them from stopping and challenging the entire machine of time, war, and mud?

A fantasy. Of reconciliation and mercy. My fellow cartridges despise me, they crave murder, to kill more and more, the soldiers of the squad feel betrayed by the young deserter who left them in a bind and forced them to dig a grave at dawn instead of catching a few extra hours of sleep before the next bombardment descends upon them, they harbor as much contempt for him as for me, the nonlive rounds, the true bullets.

A fantasy?

But if these combatants are so readily prone to violence, why would the Captain, dabbling in the lyrical language I know so well, feel the need to vow to the assembled twelve that one among them will carry not the sunset and soul and payload of the dead man for the rest of his life unless the Captain assumes—and fears—that they all harbor some deep-seated dream of peace, a longing to escape the looming sight of that slumped, familiar body and the gushing blood?

And suddenly, right now, as the rifles are checked, each one, including the one I am about to inhabit, my imagination spirals into a darker, sicker possibility.

Have I been duped by this persuasive Captain and his promise that I will be spared what the others are about to face? Or worse, could he have secretly fed each of my eleven brother cartridges the same deceitful origin tale as mine, perhaps telling them they are dummy, blank, harmless, the better to keep them calm for the lethal, simultaneous duty ahead, so that each cartridge convinces itself of its own harmlessness, just like me, just like me, and reassures its recruit, just like me, just like me, to trust that the gods of carnage have favored his selection, while all of us are equally dangerous, all of us are about to commit this crime together?

But this is not the moment, so late, to speculate about what the Captain whispered to my brothers; only I can decide what to believe, whether the immaculate fate he foresees for me is real or a sham. I must ask myself, if haltingly, with uncertain hands, I slide into the chamber: would it not have been easier to lie to me, easier for him to invent this fiction of my blamelessness than to go to the trouble of crafting one special encasement and sabotaging it, removing the live round and substituting a counterfeit, what if my gunpowder was never extracted, my flight never hollowed, nor my barrel filled with wadding, perhaps I will discover when the rifle fires that I expand and speed toward the target, splattering straight into the brain of that young man tied to the tree for eternity?

Could it be that I am not a blank, that I carry, like the others, a deadly charge?

No, no, this is too elaborate a trap, too cruel, too intricate, a waste of time, how could my Captain and maker be so calculating, why would he seem so fond of me, so haunted by his own memories, why go to such lengths to sweet-talk and confuse me when the future is so plain, my fate . . .

And then I glimpse that future. Not only the brothers heading for the young man’s body while I watch from my bloodless perch, but what follows after. None will miss their mark; they are too afraid of the Captain’s watchfulness and too proud of themselves. Some will pierce the tied body and exit into the hollow of the trunk, but most will lodge inside the dead man himself, snuggled into a bone, a kidney, the spine, the heart, the heart, remaining there as the corpse is cast into the grave the squad has dug, most of the bullets keeping him company until rain, soil, worms, and maggots do their work over hours, days, and centuries. Outlasting the slowly decaying flesh, the steel of my brothers will resist dissolution even as millennia pass, keeping the victim and each other company in their fraternal eternity, housed and nourished by the man they killed, while I, I alone, will be cast aside in a heap of solitary trash, unburied, unwept, utterly alone.

Would it not be better to be one of them? To join them at the conclusion of our journey as we were joined at the start when a mother machine spat us forth into the world, all of us, together again?

There is no time to seek an answer.

I am suddenly halted in this tangled, cyclical nocturnal reverie that leads nowhere.

Because soon, all too soon, I will learn what my fate truly is to be.

The Captain adjusts the knots and rope that bind the prisoner to the tree, raises the blindfold to meet the prisoner’s eyes; for a moment they brighten like a candle in a haunted house that will never be inhabited again, then they are extinguished as the cloth descends, those eyes no longer able to see or be seen.

He is barely older than a strand of a boy.

His mouth opens, perhaps to plead or to recall a last memory, or to mark the air that will soon be charged with bullets, but no sound comes, no final message for me, for us.

The drum roll begins, the line tightens, the weapons are primed, aimed, and ready, and the Captain clears his throat for the final command.

I am one of the twelve.

Will I endure like a seed that has stopped believing summer will return?

My comrade fires the shot.

I am about to learn the truth of who I am.

__________________________________

This excerpt comes from What She Saw by Ariel Dorfman, released by Other Press on November 10, 2026. Copyright © Ariel Dorfman. Reprinted with the permission of Other Press.

Isabela Reyes

Isabela Reyes

I write about books as quiet places where memory, imagination, and culture meet. At PLAI, I explore literature through reviews, author stories, reading reflections, and the small details that make a story stay with us long after the final page.