Curtis Sittenfeld’s Prep Becomes a TV Series: Who Might Play Lee?

November 17, 2026

Back in 2005, Curtis Sittenfeld’s debut novel Prep was the talk of the town. We debated everything from its genre to its striving protagonist, whose moral universe felt like something straight outta Wharton. Sittenfeld was praised and derided for her frankness about class and adolescent sex.

Twenty-one years on, this quintessential Millennial-era work has finally earned Hollywood’s green light. A buzzworthy adaptation steered by the One Day team is headed toward Netflix soon—but the specifics of casting remain under wraps. Enter the part I’m playing in this conversation.

The upside of moonlighting as a reader who dabbles in theatre is a certain—shall I say—knack for picking the right faces. Below are a slate of exceptionally gifted young actors currently making waves who could do justice to the difficult central figure.

*

Lee Fiora, Prep‘s central figure, is a daughter of the heartland with a fixation on a refined East Coast boarding school.

In the book, she’s described as a white brunette with romantic ideals. At school, she imagines meeting a melancholy, athletic boy who also enjoys reading and sweaters. But once Lee lands at the austere Ault academy, much of that dreamy glow begins to fade.

That’s a delicate brief for a young performer. The actor must propel the narrative while operating from a largely reactive position. My colleague McKayla Coyle suggested the rising Ella Rubin as a natural fit for the challenge.

Ella Rubin

Rubin has already dazzled streaming audiences on Sterling Point from Amazon Prize and has since carved out memorable moments in Sean Baker’s projects.

She tends to be captivating onscreen, but one performance, in particular, seems poised to capture Lee’s push-pull between ambition and insecurity. Her role as a student under Jay Duplass’s spell in The Chair reads as both bewildered and assertive—an ideal blueprint for Fiora.

Alison Oliver

The Irish actress Alison Oliver quite convincingly captured the reserved, book-loving, sweater-worshipping vibe in Hulu’s adaptation of Sally Rooney’s Conversations with Friends.

There’s also a tonal echo in the character. Much like Frances in Rooney’s novel, Lee carries a cipher-like quality—quiet among louder personalities, inclined to blend into the walls.

Oliver may hover on the edge of age-appropriateness, but she could embody Lee’s studious, slyly magnetic essence—and that zest for life that animates her ambitions.

Abby Ryder Fortson

Abby Ryder Fortson is another veteran of the adaptation trenches. She played the titular heroine in 2023’s deeply tender, underrated Are You There God? It’s Me Margaret. And she has the potential to convincingly inhabit a plausible freshman.

As Margaret, she evoked a charming, wide‑eyed bewilderment. That same throughline in her work suggests she could capture Lee’s style-over-substance tendencies, and she would likely ace the role.

Fina Strazza

My final pitch comes from the theatre world. Fina Strazza delivered a wry, jittery performance on Broadway last year in Kimberly Belflower’s John Proctor is the Villain. She embodied a devout, Southern, public‑school student—proof of her accent work and her raw nerve as an actress.

Strazza would be an ideal Lee: vulnerable, shrewd, and a touch offbeat.

Now, who should play the imperious Gates Medkowski? Or that headache-inducing crush, Cross the lacrosse player? Time will have the final word. In the meantime, keep an eye out for more stunt-casting from mid‑aughts fiction. (The Art of Fielding, anyone?)

Images via

Isabela Reyes

Isabela Reyes

I write about books as quiet places where memory, imagination, and culture meet. At PLAI, I explore literature through reviews, author stories, reading reflections, and the small details that make a story stay with us long after the final page.