My first marriage didn’t bear legal weight. Not that we broke any laws, mind you—it simply wasn’t legally recognized. I ran away with my transgender partner, Aldo, after a casual Bingo night at my place. That Bingo night itself was at least technically illegal. In the sprawling chronicle of mischief inside the Blue House—the queer, punk home I inhabited in my twenties—a seemingly small Bingo game among friends who drank beer and stubbed their cigarettes on my floor could feel trivial, yet we played for cash, so it qualified as an unlawful gambling ring. After the game wound down, Aldo and I slipped away to the apartment of Jo-Jo and Tommy, a seasoned butch-femme couple who were quietly infamous for producing award-winning lesbian porn and throwing raucous sex parties in the loft where their open marriage thrived.
Jo-Jo carried herself like a witch, and when I asked her to wed Aldo and me, she took the request with utmost gravity. Her fee was a modest $19.99, a portion of which she spent on a sheet cake from Safeway. Aldo, meanwhile, wandered the bazaar that stretched along the streets near my home—mats and blankets piled high with all sorts of goods being sold by unhoused neighbors—and found a lustrous pale-blue dress of satin. He asked whether he might buy it. Only if you vow that a pretty girl will be marrying in it, the stallholder replied, and just like that, the street blessed my wedding dress. For a veil, I stopped by a Target and discovered a crown in the children’s section, woven with ribbons the same pearly blue as my gown, studded with fake butterflies. I was prepared for my elopement.
Jo-Jo and Tommy greeted us with shots of tequila and a frosting-laden cake, decorated with improvised wedding figurines—a blue-tinted, hair-dyed plastic doll for me and a chunky, posable Batman for Aldo. Jo-Jo pinned a rhinestone brooch to my dress as a token of “something borrowed” and told us that, as she performed the ceremony, she basically became our pastor; we should seek her counsel for any marital trouble, and never pursue divorce—though we never did. Before we spoke our vows, Jo-Jo checked to make sure we weren’t battling any hidden drug dependencies. We weren’t entirely honest about those, of course, but if we confessed, they wouldn’t stay hidden. And so we were married. I felt a dizzy, intoxicating rush while I pledged myself to Aldo—surpassing even the MDMA we’d dosed a couple of nights prior. When Jo-Jo asked about addiction, I chose not to reveal my deeper secret: my addiction to love, romance, and the idea of marriage itself was still something I kept from myself.
Opening up a marriage forces you to regard your partner as a peculiar, singular creature, not merely an extension of yourself.
By the time Aldo and I eloped in 2000, the radical activist circle Gay Shame was roiling the city, staging counterprotests in the streets, interrupting Pride parades, printing biting propaganda, and leaving their mark across San Francisco. As the new millennium dawned, it became clearer to queers of a certain stripe that we could not simultaneously chase rebellious disruption and seek mainstream legitimacy. Our status as outcasts laid bare the failings of society—its racism and classism, the grotesqueries of capitalism, its ableism, lookism, and misogyny. Our vision cut through hypocrisy, recognizing the horrors Allen Ginsberg called Moloch in Howl: “Moloch the incomprehensible prison! Moloch the crossbone soulless jailhouse and Congress of sorrows! Moloch whose buildings are judgment! Moloch the vast stone of war! Moloch the stunned governments!”
Ginsberg invoked an ancient deity who demanded parents slaughter their children in his honor—and wasn’t that what modern capitalism does, families sacrificing their own for a moneyed machine? Isn’t that what assimilationist queers were buying into, chasing status points such as marriage and the right to serve in the military—participating in the nation’s dark legacy of conquest? They fought for the right to serve Moloch, and Gay Shame refused to bow to it.
As Pride grew more mainstream, contingents like Dykes on Bikes and PFLAG joined by police tasked with arresting queer sex workers, and by massive corporations with labor ethics far from radical, Gay Shame framed themselves as a virus within the system, nodding to ACT UP’s forebears and yearning for a time when queers were seen as diseased and dangerous. In their own defiant way, they believed that their strangeness held the power to dismantle the system rather than to bend it to their convenience.
“The gay elite has hijacked queer struggle, and positioned their desires as everyone’s needs—the dominant marks of straight conformity have become the ultimate signs of gay success,” wrote Gay Shame co-founder Mattilda Bernstein Sycamore in Sweatshop-Produced Rainbow Flags and Participatory Patriarchy: Why the Gay Rights Movement Is a Sham. Queer folks—especially those white, cisgender, able-bodied, and affluent—were accused of selling out, channeling resources and labor toward a boutique problem rather than directing energy to the urgent battles against police brutality, homelessness, and the violence faced by people of color, sex workers, and trans individuals. These were the real threats to queer survival.
Gay Shame flared up around the turn of the century and waned as movement dynamics shifted—partly because radical queer spaces sometimes treated each other as harshly as mainstream culture did, as Sycamore explained to the San Francisco Bay Times. The radical critique, brilliant as it was, could also be cruelly exclusionary. The movement resurfaced in 2013 in San Francisco, focusing on prison abolition and the violent effects of gentrification. The work remains valuable, though I kept a cautious distance, worried about what felt like a purity test I might fail. I agreed that the most immediate concerns of the most vulnerable queers deserved urgency, yet I also believed that everyone deserved the right to marry.
The notion that any group is barred from doing what others are allowed to do feels inherently wrong. It’s also intolerable in practice. And marriage ceremonies carry meaning for many people. They symbolize more than romance; they confer privileges—tax benefits, the right to be at a partner’s side in a hospital, the ability to marry a noncitizen, and similar protections. Of course, we should advocate for tax reform, for recognizing chosen families, and for protecting immigrant rights. Yet a vast portion of the population remains shut out by a system that grants these rights to some while denying them to others.
When conversations about queer marriage would surface in my circles—and they did, often—I’d joke that I supported gay marriage so I could weaponize it, the way straight couples do. In the spirit of Elizabeth Taylor, I imagined eight marriages, each adorned with a different, grand, thrift-store dress. How glamorous! Marry early, marry often, I’d quip.
My union with Aldo ended in a straightforward, almost banal fashion. Since we hadn’t enjoyed a “legal” marriage, no paperwork stood in the way of dissolving the bond. The only complication was that we still lived together. When Aldo admitted he wasn’t sure about staying with me, yet he did want to be with the woman he’d begun seeing while I’d been traveling, I had to ask him to leave. I even summoned his mother to coax his wild cat out of the closet where she’d been hiding during his absence. I had to tell a million people, again and again, that we were no longer together; we’d been a relatively public couple, me with my writing and him with his music. And I kept running into him and his new girlfriend, all over the place, as if nothing had happened, as if they hadn’t altered my life forever.
The final months of Aldo’s and my relationship, when he was cozying up to his newer partner while I was away performing in Brooklyn and seeing a trans painter who bore a striking resemblance to Matt Dillon, proved, in many ways, the best years of our seven-year bond. Opening our marriage had infused us with new air, helping each of us reconnect with our own identities and feel grateful for the trust, love, and encouragement that had allowed us to take that polyamorous leap. I remember smoking a cigarette from the painter’s window, exhaling into the glimmering, industrial skyline, feeling truly alive, realizing that Aldo had sparked these currents of adventure in me. I loved him deeply. Why would he choose to end this vibrant dynamic and then seek monogamy with someone else who might eventually leave him? But that’s the course of serial monogamy.
The central challenge of marriage—a sacred one, really—is to continually reawaken the aspects that first drew you to your partner, even when they’ve become hidden beneath layers that once repelled you. Opening a marriage pushes you to view your partner as a strange, singular person, not as an extension of yourself or as a cumbersome extra limb—a polyamorous boon that might actually help you reach the lofty ideals of marriage. To keep honoring the sacred uniqueness of this person, your own person. Seeing the divinity in them, and all that comes with that. It remains my favorite test, but one that requires mutual willingness to embrace.
In the run-up to the Supreme Court’s legalization of gay marriage in 2015, a particularly hysterical line of reasoning—the slippery-slope argument—said that once people could marry someone of the same gender, there wouldn’t be a barrier to marrying all sorts of inanimate objects (toasters?) or even nonhuman animals (dogs?) that no one had shown any real interest in marrying (though I know several lesbians who would happily marry their dog). One practical thread in that debate was when Samuel Alito asked aloud how a state permitting queer marriage could logically deny the right to a mixed-gender plural marriage? In his dissent, John Roberts agreed that the majority’s logic could apply to a fundamental right to polyamory as well.
Plural marriage carries a heavy cultural baggage in the United States, conjuring images of tyrannical straight men presiding over harems of women or girls forced into child marriages under certain religious sects. It’s unsettling. The HBO drama Big Love (2006) touched on the uglier manifestations of religious polygamy while presenting a more relatable, suburban version of a polygamous family. It wasn’t meant to advocate for group marriage, but it nonetheless shaped some of our ideas. Despite the familiar power imbalances and the patriarchal double standards that keep women from having multiple partners of their own, the show likely influenced Aldo’s and my decision to open our own union. Perhaps it was Chloë Sevigny’s Nicki—impulsive, stylish, with a wardrobe that whispered cottage-core with a Western edge—that drew him, and I wouldn’t have minded raiding that sister-wife closet too.
In truth, Aldo and I were probably among the rare couples who took the fantasy of that show and ran with it. Despite Big Love’s sultry appeal and the supposed liberating vibe after gay marriage, conservatives’ fear of a “polypocalypse” never materialized. In 2018, courts rejected a throuple’s bid to use Roberts’s dissent to secure a legal group marriage, and civilization marched on, seemingly unscathed.
No free love. You pay the price, everyone knows, in long nights of processing. But, even if it’s not free, exactly, maybe it’s still worth it.
An underwhelming 2012 study from the University of British Columbia claimed that outlawing polygamy and enforcing monogamy benefits culture overall. Looking at societies that practice a form of polygyny—one man with multiple wives—it argued that letting higher-status men hoard wives reduces the pool available to the average man, which then spurs violence. The study concludes that “monogamy’s main cultural evolutionary advantage over polygyny is the more egalitarian distribution of women, which reduces male competition and social problems.” I’m not eager to defend the worst examples of polygyny—where patriarchal control dominates women—but it’s equally nauseating to hear women described as property to be parceled out to men who hold some supposed right to them.
The study’s conclusions also line up with the troubling truth that most social control of women can be traced back to men’s instability. Of course, there are arguments in favor of polygyny’s redistribution of domestic duties—how many long-term couples wouldn’t love a sister-wife to take on some of the burden on certain days? There’s also the possibility of class ascent and the financial security marriage can offer a woman. Given a choice between being hoarded by the wealthy village big-timer or scraping by with a single, poor partner, I’d likely opt for that sisterhood of well-off wives.
More than ten years after queer marriage became legal, polygamy isn’t a hot cultural topic, but polyamory is. And while most prevailing theories of polyamory don’t easily accommodate a traditional dyadic marriage, what about people who are both polyamorous and marriage-minded, like the litigious throuple whose license was revoked?
In the early days of embracing polyamory as a married mother, my partner and I studied best practices from Eve Rickert and Franklin Veaux’s polyamory bible, More Than Two. We sipped coffee in bed while our toddler dozed, and I would read passages aloud. I desperately wanted to get polyamory right, because I understood that doing it poorly would make everything vanish, and between my queer true loves and my casual Tinder encounters with cisgender men, I was having far too much fun to return to “normal” life. We learned practical wisdom from the book. For instance, when jealousy arises, ask your partner for what you need instead of trying to police their dating, and when I felt envious about concert tickets for a girlfriend, I asked to join them at shows, and they surprised me with tickets to see Halsey for my birthday. Of course, COVID arrived, the concert was canceled, and eventually we divorced, but the lessons remained meaningful.
More Than Two also insisted that polyamory doesn’t automatically elevate you to a higher plane of being, a point with which I agreed. It warned against banning a partner from certain spaces or acts, urging lovers to discover the special bond they seek to protect within one another, rather than in an external fixation. The ideas and stories were powerful to absorb, even when they felt terrifyingly close to home. Like the tale of a polyamorist who married his newer partner while his long-term partner stood smiling nearby.
*
It’s intriguing to imagine multi-marriage: would it simply normalize polyamory the way gay marriage normalized queer life? Or would poly weddings become a celebration of love itself, an excuse for a party and a glamorous dress, a step toward legal equality that makes life easier and safer? My friend Mara would love to marry both of her partners, two broad-minded Aquarians who can handle her vibrant, creative Leo energy. Born in Puerto Rico, Mara now lives in Brooklyn where she writes plays. I met her at a queer artists’ retreat upstate and enjoyed talking with her, flipping tarot cards, thrifting in a small town near the rural residency. She has long, thick black hair and eyebrows I admire, a lanky frame, and a vibe of fierce freedom. She even let me pepper her with questions about her polyamory.
“Going against the grain is second nature to me,” she messages back when I ask. “Being queer in my identity and in my relationships—that freedom appeals to me. The level of maturity we’ve achieved as a throuple—there’s such peace, even when we have tough conversations or disagreements.” My heart warms, because my own open arrangements have often felt tense and charged—yet Mara’s words feel true. “There’s no free lunch,” she says. “No free love. You pay the price, often in long nights of work and processing. But even if it isn’t truly free, perhaps it’s worth it—maybe a bargain, given what you gain—more love, more sex, a truer and more intimate relationship with jealousy and insecurity. The satisfaction of living by your own code, perhaps less brainwashed than you once were.”
Mara concurs. “In the end, it’s so comforting and liberating to have these two radiant souls share themselves with me. It gives me a sense of ease that lets me do the traditional stuff like getting married, although who knows if we’re even allowed. We’re simply pursuing what we want—lots of closeness and affection and genuine love.” She weighs it all, the current restrictions on the fullest expression of her love. “We don’t have to be ‘married,’ you know?” she concedes. “Maybe we’ll just throw a massive celebration!”
I hope I’ll be invited too.
______________________________

Excerpted from Free Love: Adventures in Marriage and Polyamory by Michelle Tea. Reprinted with the permission of the publisher HarperOne, an imprint of HarperCollins. Copyright © 2026 by Michelle Tea.