“I was surrounded by phonies… They were coming in the goddam window.”
*
Seventy-five years ago today, The Catcher in the Rye first appeared on U.S. bookstore shelves, and readers still bring formidable opinions to J. D. Salinger’s groundbreaking debut. True believers and fierce critics abound. Among mid‑century American novels that have weathered the test of time, maybe only On the Road still provokes a comparably fierce divide among present-day readers. Proponents contend that Catcher remains the definitive portrait of teenage angst and estrangement, as influential and shaping a text for today’s youth as it was for the 1950s; while a substantial portion of readers, tired of being assigned eleven-grade English essays dissecting the motives of its, well, singular protagonist, push back against the book’s elevated status as a foundational text in the modern American canon and a staple of high‑school curricula nationwide.
Love it or loathe it, though, The Catcher in the Rye has endured (it still moves roughly a million copies a year, pushing its total closer to 77 million), and this milestone publication seems worthy of a retrospective. Hence this piece: a gathering of voices—from The New York Times, TIME, The New Yorker, and beyond—sharing their take on Holden Caulfield and his New York wanderings from 1951.
*
“This girl Helga, she kills me. She reads just about everything I bring into the house, and a lot of crumby stuff besides. She’s crazy about kids. I mean stories about kids. But Hel, she says there’s hardly a writer alive can write about children. Only these English guys Richard Hughes and Walter de la Mare, she says. The rest is all corny. It depresses her. That’s another thing. She can sniff a corny guy or a phony book quick as a dog smells a rat. This phoniness, it gives old Hel a pain if you want to know the truth. That’s why she came hollering to me one day, her hair falling over her face and all, and said I had to read some damn story in The New Yorker. Who’s the author? I said. Salinger, She told me, J. D. Salinger. Who’s he? I asked. How should I know, she said, just you read it.
…
“That’s the way it sounds to me, Hel said, and away she went with this crazy book. The Catcher in the Rye. What did I tell ya, she said next day. This Salinger, he’s a short story guy. And he knows how to write about kids. This book though, it’s too long. Gets kind of monotonous. And
